Next Patent: Deflection sensor
Next Patent: Deflection sensor
Plaque It!
|
[0001] This application claims priority to U.S. provisional patent application No. 60/435,161, filed Dec. 20, 2002, the contents of which are hereby incorporated by reference.
[0002] This invention relates to a force measurement system using polarization-state modulated optical polarimetry to measure directional force, pressure, and acceleration.
[0003] A “transducer” is a device that produces an electrical signal corresponding to the magnitude of a measurable physical property. Transducers are frequently used to measure forces such as tension and compression. The prior art typically measures force using strain gauges, deflection transducers, null-displacement transducers, and piezoceramic transducers.
[0004] Strain gauge transducers are typically constructed of metal or semiconductor filaments placed on a backing sheet. The gauge is rigidly attached to a body to be subjected to strain, such as flexible beams or stacked cylinders. Upon deformation of these beams, the strain gauge wire is stretched elastically, which changes the resistance of the wire. By monitoring the resistance, the applied force, or “load” can be determined by referring to transducer-specific calibration curves. Strain gauges are susceptible to electronic noise, making measurement of small forces difficult and subject to inaccuracy. Strain gauges are also subject to errors introduced by temperature variations. Further, a lack of rigidity of the transducer can result in force plate deflections that can exceed 10-20 micrometers, limiting the transducer's resolution and, thus their usefulness, for small-force measurements.
[0005] Deflection transducers are similar in function to strain gauge transducers in that the deflection of a beam or a diaphragm is measured by monitoring changes in capacitance or inductance of a device, or by optically measuring the amount of deflection. The deflection versus load characteristic of a deflection transducer is calibrated using known weights. Unfortunately, deflection transducers suffer from the same noise susceptibility and small-force measurement limitations as strain gauges.
[0006] A null-displacement transducer is yet another form of transducer. A null-displacement transducer measures forces through optical means or via a linear variable displacement transducer (“LVDT”). The displacement of a rod attached to a load plate is monitored when the plate is subjected to an axial load. A set of coils surrounding the rod effectively act as a solenoid or servo-mechanical system, permitting the application of enough current to move the rod back to its “unloaded” position. The computed load is proportional to the measured drive current. Null-displacement transducers suffer from excessive deflection and a poor response time (typically greater than 1-5 seconds), making them unsuitable for measuring small or rapidly changing forces.
[0007] Lastly, there are piezoceramic type transducers that generate an electrical charge corresponding to a load when the crystalline structure of the transducer is distorted by the load. Having a high-impedance measurement system, the charge buildup can be measured and scaled to the load. Piezoceramic transducers have the advantage of requiring little deflection and reasonably good resolution. However, the charge can dissipate over time, making this type of transducer preferably for use with only for transient loads, e.g., cyclical loads.
[0008] Recent advances in micro-level research, including micromotion, combinatorial design of drugs, microfluidics, biomimetic adhesive research, and the mechanical response of biological tissue has reinforced an existing need for high sensitivity, robust force transducers capable of measuring both transient and static loads. Commercially available force transducers capable of measuring transient responses generally have a resolution of approximately 10
[0009] According to the present invention, a method is disclosed for a compact, high sensitivity, wide dynamic range force transducer and measurement system capable of measuring static, dynamic, and transient force changes in tension and compression. The operating principle, known as “force sensing linkage,” is based upon measuring the change in optical properties at the molecular level of a pre-stressed polymer material under a loaded condition. The linkage acts as a load sensor which measures both compression and tension forces. The molecular deformation of the linkage is analyzed using miniature optical components arranged as a polarization state modulated polarimeter capable of birefringence measurements on the order of 10
[0010] The transducer is capable of directional force, pressure, and acceleration measurements and is extremely accurate for measuring small-force levels. Since the force transducer of the present invention is based upon optical techniques it is relatively immune to electronic noise and provides for measurement of rapidly changing loads. The invention can be miniaturized to accommodate a wide variety of measurements requiring miniature force and/or pressure measurement devices such as medical devices. Examples of some potential uses for medical transducers include, without limitation, inter-cranial pressure lines, diabetic foot stress sensor arrays, and inner ear pressure sensors used for the diagnosis and treatment of Meniere's disease.
[0011] One object of the present invention is a birefringent linkage transducer for measuring force comprising a polymer having generally uniaxially oriented polymer chains. In one embodiment of the present invention, the polymer is polystyrene.
[0012] Another object of the present invention is a system for measuring force applied to a transducer, comprising: a source of coherent light having an output; a linear polarizer optically coupled to the output of coherent light, effective to polarize the coherent light passing therethrough; a variable retarder optically coupled to the polarized light; a polarization state modulator optically coupled to the variable retarder to periodically vary the phase of the polarized light passing through the variable retarder; a birefringent linkage transducer having generally uniaxially oriented polymer chains, the transducer being optically coupled to the phase-modulated, polarized light effective to generate a stress information optical signal when the phase-modulated, polarized light passes through the transducer; a linear analyzer optically coupled to the optical signal to polarize the stress information optical signal; a photodetector coupled to the polarized optical signal to derive stress tensors for the transducer, wherein the stress tensor data corresponds to the amount of force applied to the transducer.
[0013] Yet another object of the invention is a system for measuring force applied to a transducer, comprising: a source of coherent light having an output; a first collimator optically coupled to the output, effective to concentrate the light into a beam of coherent light; a first linear polarizer optically coupled to the beam of coherent light, effective to polarize the beam; a polarization state modulator optically coupled to the first linear polarizer to periodically vary the phase of the beam of polarized, coherent light emitted from the first linear polarizer; a beam splitter optically coupled to the polarization state modulator to split the phase modulated beam of light into first and second phase modulated sub-beams; a second collimator optically coupled to the first phase modulated sub-beam; a third collimator optically coupled to the second phase modulated sub-beam; a birefringent linkage transducer having generally uniaxially oriented polymer chains, the transducer being optically coupled to the second and third collimators such that the first and second phase modulated sub-beams pass through the transducer generally orthogonally and intersect within the linkage, interaction at the intersection of the first and second sub-beams generating first and second stress information optical signals containing phase information from which the force applied to the linkage can be derived; a first linear analyzer optically coupled to the first stress information optical signal to linearly polarize the first stress information optical signal; a second linear analyzer optically coupled to the second stress information optical signal to linearly polarize the second stress information optical signal; an optical multiplexer optically coupled to the first and second stress information optical signals to combine the first and second stress information optical signals into a multiplexed stress information optical signal; a photodetector optically coupled to the optical multiplexer to decode the multiplexed optical stress information signal into a corresponding electrical signal; and a signal recovery processor electrically coupled to the photodetector effective to derive phase retardance and molecular orientation angle and derive stress tensors for the transducer, the stress tensors corresponding to the amount of force applied to the transducer.
[0014] Still another object of the present invention is a system for measuring force applied to a transducer, comprising: a source of coherent light having an output; a polarizer optically coupled to the output of coherent light to polarize the coherent light passing therethrough; a variable retarder optically coupled to the polarizer to vary the optical orientation of the light; a modulator electrically coupled to the variable retarder to modulate the light by periodically varying the orientation of the retarder with respect to the light; a beam splitter to split the light into a first light sub-beam and a second light sub-beam; a birefringent polymer linkage transducer having a generally uniaxially oriented polymer chains, the linkage being arranged such that the first light sub-beam and second light sub-beam are optically coupled to the linkage generally orthogonally and intersect within the linkage; first and second optical signals output from the linkage transducer, the first and second optical signals resulting from interaction at the intersection of the first and second sub-beams within the linkage transducer, each optical signal containing phase information from which the force applied to the linkage can be derived; a first linear analyzer optically coupled to the first optical signal to polarize the first optical signal; a second linear analyzer optically coupled to the second optical signal to polarize the second optical signal; a first photodetector optically coupled to the first linear analyzer to derive the force information from the first optical signal; a second photodetector optically coupled to the second linear analyzer to derive the force information from the second optical signal; and a recovery processor electrically coupled to the first and second photodetectors effective to derive optical phase retardance and molecular orientation information of the transducer in three dimensions, wherein individual stress tensors in three dimensions are derived from the optical phase retardance and molecular orientation information, the stress tensors relating to the force exerted upon the transducer.
[0015] Yet another object of the present invention is a method for using a birefringent transducer for measuring applied force, comprising the steps of: generating a beam of coherent light; polarizing the beam of coherent light with a linear polarizer; modulating the phase of the polarized beam of light with a variable retarder; passing the modulated beam of light through a birefringent transducer, the birefringent transducer having generally uniaxially oriented polymer chains effective to generate a stress information optical signal; passing the stress information optical signal through a linear analyzer to polarize the optical signal; and deriving stress tensors for the transducer from the polarized optical signal, wherein the stress tensor data corresponds to the amount of force applied to the transducer.
[0016] Further features of the inventive embodiments will become apparent to those skilled in the art to which the embodiments relate from reading the specification and claims with reference to the accompanying drawings, in which:
[0017]
[0018]
[0019]
[0020]
[0021]
[0022]
[0023]
[0024]
[0025]
[0026]
[0027]
[0028]
[0029]
[0030]
[0031]
[0032]
[0033]
[0034]
[0035]
[0036]
[0037]
[0038]
[0039]
[0040]
[0041]
[0042]
[0043]
[0044]
[0045]
[0046]
[0047]
[0048]
[0049]
[0050]
[0051] 1. Overview of Birefringence
[0052] Birefringence (termed Δn′) is defined as the anisotropy in a material's refractive index with respect to the polarization state of light propagating through it. In an optically transparent polymer material under stress, the orientation and degree of deformation of the polymer molecules cause an anisotropic polarization. If a light propagates along the z-direction through a birefringent material, the x and y components of its electrical field vector will be different from one another. This results in a phase difference or retardance (termed δ) as the light traverses the birefringent material. If the material is not dichroic, then the retardance is related directly to its birefringence. This can be expressed by Equation 1:
[0053] where n
[0054] where τ
[0055] In order to compute an applied stress or force acting upon a polymer linkage, the path length dependence must be known. The applied stress (or force) is a function of birefringence, molecular orientation angle and stress optical coefficient. The birefringence depends upon optical phase retardation, which is also a function of the optical path length as shown in Equation 4:
[0056] Where δ is the optical phase retardance, d is the optical pathlength through the sample material, λ is the wavelength of light and Δn′ is the material birefringence.
[0057] Path length dependence with no stress applied to the linkage is linear. The dependence of the optical phase retardance on optical path length will also vary in accordance with the amount of applied stress. This relationship will become nonlinear near the yield point of the polymer linkage material.
[0058] 2. Birefringent Transducer Construction
[0059] Oriented polymer “linkages” or transducers are preferred for use in birefringence measurements. Any conventional birefringent material known in the art having a generally uniaxially orient polymer chain may be used. Polystyrene is favored because it has a high degree of birefringence, measured as the refractive index difference normal and parallel to the main chain of the polymer. In addition, polystyrene has a high modulus and yield stress, resulting in a stiff linkage with little permanent plastic deformation until high stresses are reached. Lastly, polystyrene, being a common thermoplastic, is both relatively easy to process and to obtain in raw form. Raw polystyrene in extruded pellet form is preferred over powder, as transducers molded from powder are prone to bubble entrainment which can hamper transducer function due to distortion of optical signals that pass through the transducer.
[0060] A birefringent transducer preferably has a high degree of permanent polymer orientation. Orientation in polymers can be obtained by subjecting the polymer to specific flow fields which stretch out the polymer chains while in a molten phase (i.e. when the polymer is above its glass transition or melting temperature), then quenching the sample prior to relaxation of the polymer chains. Polystyrene has a glass transition temperature of about 100° C.
[0061] An example of a polymer chain before and after the application of an orienting flow is shown diagrammatically in
[0062] Transducers having uniaxially oriented polymer chains may be obtained via extensional and channel die flow processes which further orient the polymer chains. An extensional flow process is illustrated in
[0063] Channel dies may also be used to prepare transducers having oriented-chain linkages. A channel die generates a constrained planar flow field for a polymer while in its molten phase, allowing generally uniaxial orientation of a polymer. An example channel die
[0064] Polystyrene pellets (not shown) are preferably first molded into relatively thin sheets, sectioned into generally rectangular strips, then placed into channel
[0065] After one compression cycle (i.e.,
[0066] To determine the bulk degree of chain orientation, the linkages may be annealed above their glass transition temperature until they have relaxed to a steady-state length. The residual orientation, or strain ε, is computed from the change in length L normalized by the initial length L
[0067] The amount of relaxation is proportional to the uniformity of orientation of chain linkages.
[0068] 3. Light Modulating Optical Trains
[0069] A. Liquid Crystal Polarization Modulator
[0070] Prior art systems for birefringence measurement (termed “electro-mechanical modulators” herein) typically use a dual crystal electro-optic modulator, a conventional Pockels cell, a photo-elastic modulator or a simpler system wherein an optical retardation plate is rotated with a mechanical motorized system. Although the mechanical rotation system can accommodate large aperture sizes the rotation speed is limited due to the mechanical moving parts, limiting the sensitivity of the measurement system. Further, the necessarily large physical size of the components of an electro-mechanical birefringence measurement system do not permit construction of a compact device. A liquid crystal modulator has several advantages over electro-mechanical modulators including smaller size, lower cost, a much larger aperture for ease of alignment, and the potential for two-dimensional birefringence measurement. Liquid crystal retarders are essentially optically anisotropic media that act locally as a uniaxial retardation plate and exhibit optical birefringence. Generating an E-field across the liquid crystal media produces different polarization states for the media, depending on the applied voltage. Thus, a time-varying E-field may be employed as polarization modulator.
[0071] Accurate, stable measurements of birefringence call for non-intrusive, compact instruments that modulate the polarization of light. As previously noted, prior systems for measuring birefringence use an electro-mechanical modulator. A significant drawback of using an electro-mechanical modulator is a need to closely align the instrument, since the modulator typically has only about a 4 mm diameter aperture through which the light beam must pass. Thus, a slight misalignment may compromise the accuracy of the retardance and birefringence measurement. An advantage of using a liquid crystal modulator according to an embodiment of the present invention is an inherently larger diameter aperture that allows easy, consistent alignment, aiding the accuracy of the instrument. Thus, the liquid crystal modulator allows greater ease of use without compromising its accuracy.
[0072] B. Liquid Crystal Modulation Characteristics
[0073] A conventional liquid crystal variable retarder comprises a plurality of liquid crystals placed between a pair of optically transparent or translucent elements or grids. Liquid crystals are usually in a liquid state, but they also exhibit properties of a solid crystal. When the crystals are exposed to an external electrical field applied between the elements the orientation of the crystals will change. This property can be used to control the phase of light passing through the liquid crystals.
[0074] Nematic liquid crystals are optically equivalent to a linear waveplate whose optical axis is fixed, but whose birefringence is a function of the voltage applied to the grids. As the applied voltage increases above 0 volts the birefringence changes from typically about 0.2 nm/cm to near zero. The resulting change is the optical path length for a linearly polarized light propagating parallel to the extraordinary axis, (Δn′)d, where d is the thickness of the film and Δn′ the change in birefringence. Factors influencing the birefringence of liquid crystals for a given voltage include the type of liquid crystal materials, spacing between grids (“thickness”), and temperature.
[0075] Liquid crystal variable retarders (“LCVRs”) are tunable waveplates that, in conjunction with linear polarizers, form the circular and oriented linear polarizers that are required to characterize the polarization of an unknown light beam in a Stokes Polarimeter. The response time of an LCVR depends on several factors, such as the liquid crystal layer thickness, viscosity, temperature and surface treatment as well as the driving electrical waveform. The response time is also sensitive to the direction of the retardance change as well as the absolute value of the liquid crystal retardance. In general, the response time of an LCVR is much faster when using a higher electric field potential. The electric field applies an external “torque” to each liquid crystal molecule, but when the field is removed or switched to a lower value, interactions between liquid crystal molecules provide the dominant forces. These interactive forces are much weaker than the torque caused by an external electrical field, leading to a slower relaxation time. In many applications it is only necessary to quickly switch in one direction, such as with a sawtooth wave as shown in
[0076]
[0077] Liquid crystal birefringence measurement system
[0078] Different types of voltage modulation of LCVR
[0079] With reference to
[0080] Liquid crystal modulator
[0081] C. Calculation of Retardance and Orientation Angle
[0082] The optical phase retardance must be computed prior to making any force measurements. The molecular orientation angle of the polymer linkage material must be computed if additional shear stress measurements or complete three-dimensional stresses are to be made. These quantities are directly related to force, pressure and stress measurements through equations 2 and 3.
[0083] From the input Stokes vector of the linearly polarized light and the Mueller matrices of all the sequences of the optical elements, the Glann Thompson polarizer, the liquid crystal retarder, sample material, the cross polarizer (i.e., the second Glann Thompson polarizer), the intensity results of the second and fourth harmonics are related to the first and second orders of the Bessel functions and a stress tensor M. The modulated output intensities at the second harmonic and the fourth harmonics are given by Equations 6 and 7:
[0084] The results of the derivation of Mueller matrices showing that, as the sinusoidal input voltage, A is increased, the second harmonic, I
[0085] These variables are used to obtain the instantaneous measurements for retardance, δ, and the orientation angle, χ.
[0086] D. Liquid Crystal Modulator Calibration
[0087] Liquid crystal modulator calibration must be performed if a liquid crystal variable retarder (LCVR) is used as a polarization state modulator. The calibration point (i.e., the point at which the LCVR drive voltage is set) must be known in order to determine variables 1-3, discussed above.
[0088] To greatly simplify the analysis and calculation of birefringence, the zero order Bessel function, J
[0089] One method of calibrating the liquid crystal modulator is achieved by using the general arrangement of
[0090] With continued reference to
[0091] An LCVR
[0092] The sample quarter waveplate may be replaced with a sixteenth waveplate made of quartz and the same calculations made. The sixteenth waveplate has the retardance illustrated in Equation 8:
[0093] The result is a calibration check using a sample of known birefringence.
[0094] The average maximum experimental retardance measurement according to an embodiment of the present invention is 0.4172 radians. This corresponds to a 6.43 percent error. With the plot of retardance and orientation angle, the birefringence may be calculated using Equation 4. If the thickness of the quartz is about 1.97 mm, a zero-order birefringence measurement of Δn′=2.3077·10
[0095] Knowing the stress-optical coefficient from tabulated values well-known in the art, or by calculating it through polarimetric measurement, the stress tensors may be calculated by using equations 1 and 2. This method can be used to measure the retardance and orientation angle of an unknown sample and then calculate the birefringence and stress of the material. Many different types of optical materials can be applied, including polymers, plastics, fluids and lenses.
[0096] E. Polarization-Maintaining Fiber-Coupled LCVR
[0097] Coupling of the modulated laser beam to a polarization-maintaining (“PM”) optical fiber and observing modulation depth is now considered. The general arrangement of the input section of a fiber-optic coupled LCVR is shown in
[0098] F. Two-Axis Force Testing
[0099] To facilitate measurement of two stress axes simultaneously, two small mirrors and a approximately 50/50 beam splitter
[0100] G. Electro-Optic Modulator
[0101] An electro-optic modulator subsystem is shown in
[0102] 4. Force-Measurement Systems
[0103] A. Closed-Path Force Measurement System
[0104] A block diagram of one embodiment of the present invention is illustrated in
[0105] The signal recovery processor
[0106]
[0107] B. Open-Path Optical Force Measurement System
[0108]
[0109] C. Comparison of Measurement Systems
[0110] The embodiment of
[0111] 5. Force Measurement
[0112] With reference to
[0113] The shear stress is also computed as:
[0114] where C is the birefringent material's stress-optical coefficient, Δn′ is the material's birefringence and χ is the instantaneous orientation angle of the molecular polymer chains with respect to the flow direction. Setting equations 9 and 10 equal produces the following relationship relating the birefringence and molecular orientation angle to the directional force applied to the polymer linkage:
[0115] The present invention may be used to measure force, pressure and/or shear stress, preferably in terms of Newtons (kg*m/s
[0116] 6. Advantages of the Present Invention
[0117] The present invention provides a number of advantages over prior art force measurement systems, such as the mechanical systems previously discussed. For example, a force measurement system according to the present invention is able to measure small masses, such as a one-third milligram mass with 100 mm thick thin film polystyrene linkage. Other thinner linkages may be able to resolve even lower stresses. In addition, due to mathematical ratios inherent in the offset homodyne signal recovery techniques, the system performs with less than half of one percent measurement signal drift.
[0118] A further advantage of the present invention is that the force measurement system is able to resolve both positive and negative stresses. The sensitivity of the force measurement system depends on polymer linkage thickness, material composition, the amount of pre-stress applied to linkage material and environmental factors such as temperature.
[0119] A yet further advantage of the present invention is that the force measurement system is able to detect and measure fast transient loads, on the order of about 4.2 kHz using a 42 kHz polarization modulation frequency. The fast response allows measurement of forces that would otherwise not be detected.
[0120] It should be noted that there is a range where a linear relationship exists between applied force and optical phase retardance produced by the polymer linkage within the force transducer. This relationship determines the useful force measurement range for each polymer linkage that may be used. These ranges are different for different materials, different optical pathlengths (material thicknesses) and different geometric configurations. The relationship between the applied force and optical phase retardance produced by the polymer linkage within a particular force transducer becomes nonlinear toward the lower and upper force measurement capability ranges of the transducer. Force, pressure or stress measurements can also be computed in this nonlinear range, but with less precision toward the asymptotic boundaries.
[0121] 7. Example Embodiments of the Present Invention
[0122] A. Measuring Foot Stresses
[0123] The present invention enables the measurement of small forces, including small transient forces present for only a short period of time. An example application where the present invention may be utilized to advantage is with stress sensor arrays used in connection with diabetic patients.
[0124] Diabetic patients frequently suffer from neuropathy. Diabetic neuropathy is a nerve disorder caused by diabetes. Symptoms of neuropathy include numbness and/or pain in the hands, feet, or legs. The damage to nerves often results in loss of reflexes and muscle weakness. The foot often becomes wider and shorter, the gait changes, and foot ulcers appear as pressure is put on parts of the foot that are less protected. Because of the loss of sensation, injuries may go unnoticed and often become infected. If ulcers or foot injuries are not treated in time, the infection may involve the bone and require amputation. Thus, there is a need for a sensor capable of monitoring the small, transient pressure and shear at various points of the sole of a diabetic patient's foot, in order to evaluate the effect of neuropathy on the patient and to take therapeutic steps directed at preventing foot injury and infection.
[0125] A foot stress sensor array
[0126] B. Other Embodiments
[0127] The present invention may be utilized to determine forces or stresses, plot force or stress as a function of time. Other uses include, but are not limited to, determining skin stress in diabetic foot patients, measuring transient blood pressure in each heartbeat, determining fast (such as about 10 kHz) transient stresses in rheometric or granular flow systems, and measuring small amounts of powders applied quickly in pharmaceutical drug manufacturing processes.
[0128] 8. Diode Laser
[0129]
[0130] The diode laser
[0131] 9. Conclusion
[0132] While this invention has been shown and described with respect to a detailed embodiment thereof, it will be understood by those skilled in the art that various changes in form and detail thereof may be made without departing from the scope of the claims of the invention.